Given Up for You Page 18
As the film began I indulged in the rare pleasure of deciding which member of the on-screen lesbian couple I most resembled. The last film that had given me the chance for this game was The Kids Are All Right, when after a few scenes I settled on the Julianne Moore character, right up until she has creepy bad sex with her sperm donor, at which point I decided I was a less uptight version of Annette Bening.
This time my alter ego was clear from the first moment. I was Therese Belivet, the young shopgirl, the seduced. The one who can’t quite believe what she wants, what she suddenly, absurdly, can’t live without. It was pleasing to watch her move across the camera’s dreamy Vaseline-smeared lens, both blurry and bright. She made me want to tame my hair and find my pearl earrings, buy a tweed skirt, order creamed spinach and eggs. She made me want to smoke.
I began to sour on the movie when Carol’s husband leaves town with their daughter, threatening Carol with a child custody suit if she doesn’t put a stop to her lesbian ways. This is a story line I detest: the woman who sacrifices motherhood at the altar of desire. I hate the story line because of my own telescopic and terrified response to it, which has always been: keep the child at all costs. As I watched, I thought, Oh, Carol. Just don’t. Go home, be quiet, keep secret. Have sex with your husband, tape up your marriage. What could matter more than your child?
But then soon enough Carol and Therese are on the road, they are in a hotel room, and Carol’s mouth is on Therese’s body. And in that moment of watching them I knew what could matter more than anything or anyone else. I knew just as well as they did. So I was Therese, but I was also Carol. I was the girl who can’t believe she wants it; I was the woman who will give up what she loves to keep it.
I had long kept my distance from the Carols of history, lesbians who lost everything to be themselves. I held them all at arm’s length, preferring to think of my love affair as singular and apolitical, removed from time and even from my own identity, as though Chris were the only woman I would ever desire, the narrative of my sexual identity complete in the narrative of our sex. Kelly and her politics, Chris at the statehouse protesting the protestors—I had wanted to keep my distance even from the struggles of those closest to me.
But there I was sitting next to my wife—the woman with whom I had two children and a life insurance policy—watching a spectacle of harm and loss that I could not push away. Those women were my history, my foremothers. My life was built on the lives of women like Carol; my children existed because their children were taken from them and they refused to go home and keep the secret.
But that wasn’t all. I watched the pained glances, the letter held too tightly, the phone receiver held too long. Carol’s anxiety while she waits, broken, chastened, for a supervised visit with her daughter. Carol wasn’t just my history. She wasn’t just the before. I had more in common with Carol than I had, for so long, wanted to admit.
All those years ago I walked into a basement chapel and tasted the divine. I swam in deep waters of belief. For a time I was known and loved and home, and I believed great things would come to me. But what came to me instead was another desire just as profound, and entirely irreconcilable. The world I was born into was fuller than Carol’s world but it was still broken.
Bit by bit I forged a new belief, and it was meaningful and complicated and real. But it wasn’t better than the one I might have had if I had been allowed to remain a Catholic. I would have liked to do that. I would still like to. I would like a wider life; I would like to move through the world and claim anything that moves me, anything that expands my experience of being human. I would like not to be the person who watches a movie in which a woman loses her child and feels a kinship with that woman.
And yet. Carol’s mouth on Therese’s body.
I have known since I was twenty-four that I couldn’t live without that. When I was a girl like Therese, a seed cracked in the fire of my wanting, and my whole life sprouted from it. It’s funny to think of my life this way, passionate and urgent, destined. Surely it doesn’t look it, here as a now forty-something woman with two children and a dog, a weedy garden, a mortgage. This is the life born of that fire? This life is essential and wild, the only possible life? Yes. Yes it is.
For years I was haunted by the shadow of the woman I thought I would become, the Catholic who crossed her children before they left for sleepaway camp, believing in the blessing and protection of her prayers, her sign. She was a second, impossible self, and she was maddening. But she’s dear to me now. I no longer see her impossibility as a result of my weakness, my lack of faith, of determination. She’s impossible because this world will not abide her, not yet. But I know her heart. I know what she believes.
On my office wall there is a photo of the Pantheon in Rome on Pentecost. In the photo countless blood-red rose petals are falling from the dome’s oculus. The petals are a symbol, a dramatic reenactment of the first Pentecost when the Holy Spirit arrived as fire, igniting the apostles with the ability to speak in tongues that the people around them heard, and understood, in their own varied and native languages. Pentecost is the miracle that built the Church. In the photo, robed priests and worshippers reach for the petals. A child lies on the marble floor as though in a field, a red and fragrant sea. I hung the photo because I’m planning to go to Rome for Pentecost someday. I will stand under the Pantheon’s domed ceiling, shoulder to shoulder with people of a faith that I love but can’t claim, and I will wait for the petals to fall.
Acknowledgments
Thank you first to Heather Abel, editor and friend of my dreams, who urged me into the undiscovered country of memory and helped me make sense—and sentences—from what I found there. You made every page, and every day spent writing it, better.
I am deeply grateful to Joan Larkin for her early and sustained enthusiasm, and to all those at the University of Wisconsin Press who gave this book their time and attention, especially Raphael Kadushin, David Bergman, Amber Rose, Sheila Leary, Sheila McMahon, and Michelle Wing.
Rilla Askew and John Wideman taught me how to tell a story, and for that I can’t thank them enough. Shauna Seliy, Brian Jordan, and the late Jim Foley offered marvelous camaraderie and still do, on earthly and astral planes.
Enormous gratitude to the West Cummington Church for being my home, and to Stephen Philbrick, who, to borrow his words, is a bright star in my shabby firmament. And thank you to Penny Schultz, for all the joy.
Rachel Jenkins gave me the room I needed, when I needed it. Erin O’Donnell, Karen Stevens, and Susan Warner took care of my girls so that I could write. Deborah Balmuth, Alisa Greenbacher, and Lori Shine read earlier drafts and responded with generosity and smarts. MB Caschetta and Cathi Hanauer made essential connections. Thank you all.
Thank you to Kelly Anderson for being family; to Cyndy Sperry for showing me how to be a mother and an artist; to Tim Davis and Susan Garsoe for a western desk; and Patsy Kauffman-Barber, Jen Nates, Alison Rogers, and Karin Wallestad for sustaining friendship.
And thanks to my family. The Corsacs brought me in with so much laughter and love. Thank you. Love and thanks to all the O’Neills and all the Whites, most especially to the world’s best parents, Catherine and Jerry White, who filled deep wells of confidence and worth. And to my brother, Jerry, and sister, Rebecca, for faith and loyalty and for letting me have the middle seat in the VW bus. I would go anywhere with you two.
Grace and June, my darling girls, thank you for every last thing. I still can’t believe you’re mine.
Deepest thanks to Chris. Without you there is no story. Thank you for trusting me with it. Thank you for bringing it—and me—to life.
And one last debt of thanks: To the generations of LGBT people who wrote and spoke and marched, strategized and organized and testified and lay down in the streets so that I could have this life. Thank you. And thank you to the people who are still fighting, because the struggle is far from over. Thank you for your bravery and your vision. Thank you for being always
on the side of love.
LIVING OUT
Gay and Lesbian Autobiographies
David Bergman, Joan Larkin, and Raphael Kadushin
FOUNDING EDITORS
The Other Mother: A Lesbian’s Fight for Her Daughter
Nancy Abrams
An Underground Life: Memoirs of a Gay Jew in Nazi Berlin
Gad Beck
Gay American Autobiography: Writings from Whitman to Sedaris
Edited by David Bergman
Surviving Madness: A Therapist’s Own Story
Betty Berzon
You’re Not from Around Here, Are You? A Lesbian in Small-Town America
Louise A. Blum
Just Married: Gay Marriage and the Expansion of Human Rights
Kevin Bourassa and Joe Varnell
Two Novels: “Development” and “Two Selves”
Bryher
The Hurry-Up Song: A Memoir of Losing My Brother
Clifford Chase
The Pox Lover: An Activist’s Decade in New York and Paris
Anne-christine d’Adesky
In My Father’s Arms: A Son’s Story of Sexual Abuse
Walter A. de Milly III
Lawfully Wedded Husband: How My Gay Marriage Will Save the American Family
Joel Derfner
Midlife Queer: Autobiography of a Decade, 1971–1981
Martin Duberman
Self-Made Woman: A Memoir
Denise Chanterelle DuBois
The Black Penguin
Andrew Evans
The Man Who Would Marry Susan Sontag: And Other Intimate Literary Portraits of the Bohemian Era
Edward Field
Body, Remember: A Memoir
Kenny Fries
In the Province of the Gods
Kenny Fries
Travels in a Gay Nation: Portraits of LGBTQ Americans
Philip Gambone
Autobiography of My Hungers
Rigoberto González
What Drowns the Flowers in Your Mouth: A Memoir of Brotherhood
Rigoberto González
Widescreen Dreams: Growing Up Gay at the Movies
Patrick E. Horrigan
The End of Being Known: A Memoir
Michael Klein
Through the Door of Life: A Jewish Journey between Genders
Joy Ladin
The Last Deployment: How a Gay, Hammer-Swinging Twentysomething Survived a Year in Iraq
Bronson Lemer
Eminent Maricones: Arenas, Lorca, Puig, and Me
Jaime Manrique
Body Blows: Six Performances
Tim Miller
1001 Beds: Performances, Essays, and Travels
Tim Miller
Cleopatra’s Wedding Present: Travels through Syria
Robert Tewdwr Moss
Good Night, Beloved Comrade: The Letters of Denton Welch to Eric Oliver
Edited and with an introduction by Daniel J. Murtaugh
Taboo
Boyer Rickel
Secret Places: My Life in New York and New Guinea
Tobias Schneebaum
Wild Man
Tobias Schneebaum
Sex Talks to Girls: A Memoir
Maureen Seaton
Treehab: Tales from My Natural, Wild Life
Bob Smith
Outbound: Finding a Man, Sailing an Ocean
William Storandt
Given Up for You: A Memoir of Love, Belonging, and Belief
Erin O. White